Best AllSpice Substitutes

Best AllSpice Substitutes

Looking for an allspice substitute? Cloves, nutmeg are few allspice substitutes.

Why trust us?

Our reviews are research-based, and all trials and testings are conducted in-house over days and weeks. We have a strict no-free-sample policy to ensure our reviews are fair and impartial.

All the cooking enthusiasts in the world, love to try it out new dishes as well as cuisines, and each n every cuisine uses unique ingredients which sets them apart. Allspice is one such ingredient, which is used for cooking various kinds of cooking, even beverages.

Allspice is made up of dried berries of a plant named as Pimenta dioica and is also called as Jamaica pepper, myrtle pepper, pimenta, or pimento. This versatile spice is used for cooking cuisines like middle eastern, Caribbean, Latin American cuisines, etc. now that you are aware of what allspice is about, let us take a look at Allspice substitute, especially when you run out of them in the kitchen and need it urgently.


How Can You Use Allspice?

Allspice can be used as a whole as well as a grounded form. Once allspice is in a grounded form, it will lose the pungency. So it is better to use the grounded form instead of the whole form. The whole form is used for making stews and soups and the grounded form can be used for making desserts.


Allspice can be used in stews, soups and desserts.

What Can I Use Instead Of Allspice?

We have all been in this place, where we run out of spices during cooking. Don’t worry; we have the answer to the common question – what can I substitute for allspice? You can easily get allspice replacement by using some of the common spices mentioned in our Allspice substitute list.


Ground Allspice Substitute

The best replacement of ground allspice is whole allspice. You can add it to a dish while making it, but make sure you remove it before serving.

If you don’t have the whole allspice, then you can mix, cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg together and use them instead. The best allspice ground substitute is an allspice clove.


Whole Allspice

You can use ground allspice instead of the whole spice, you will have to use about ¼ to ½ tsp. Or you can use cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg in your dish. Please be mindful of the amount of nutmeg being used, as it can overpower the dish.

One thing you have to keep in mind is that the grounded spices will have a more intense flavor than whole spices, so add accordingly. You will have to add them slowly until the time you don’t reach the desired taste. The grounded spices also change the color of the dish while whole spices don’t.

You can always add the same amount of cloves in exchange for allspice berries if you are someone who prefers using whole spices.

Ad: Join Mishry's Sampling Community
Ad 13 - Share Your voice


Whole allspice and ground allspice can be used as substitutes for each other.


What Does Allspice Taste Like?

Everyone describes Allspice’s taste as a combination of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, which is why these three spices are great as an allspice replacement. This also the reason why it has been named as Allspice for its unique flavour.

Allspice is one of those spices which is used all over the world. Allspice is used for cooking all sorts of food as well as desserts. This is probably the reason why Allspice is consumed all over the world. Now, let us learn how to make Allspice at home.


Ingredients For Making Allspice Substitute At Home


Allspice substitute can be made at home as well.

One tablespoon nutmeg (grounded)

One tablespoon cloves (grounded)

One tablespoon cinnamon (grounded)

Add these three ingredients in the bowl and mix. If they are in the whole form, grind them and then mix them and store it in an airtight container.

For the people who like Allspice but in a milder form, reduce the quantity of nutmeg and cloves to half.


Frequently Asked Questions

We have answered few interesting FAQs about AllSpice.

1. Is Five Spice Same As Allspice?

No, the five-spice is not as same as Allspice. Five spices are made of cloves, Chinese cinnamon, fennel seeds, Sichuan pepper, and star anise, whereas the Allspice is a dried berry of a plant.

2. What is ground allspice made of?

Ground allspice is made with Allspice berries. A tablespoon of ground allspice is equivalent to six whole allspice berries.

3. Can you substitute Allspice for nutmeg?

If you are wondering whether you can substitute Allspice for nutmeg, yes, you definitely can. You can replace Allspice with equal amounts of nutmeg.

Fun Fact – When Allspice was first discovered, the discoverers were confused because of its taste, which is why they named it Allspice.



As you can see, Allspice is an ingredient that is commonly used in every household. Moreover, finding the replacement of Allspice is also not very difficult, because you can use the ingredients present in your kitchen to give the same taste and color to your dish.


Subscribe to our Newsletter

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify Me
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Available for Amazon Prime